If you’ve been following the Fantastic Beasts saga, you already know the third film brought more than just magical creatures — it arrived under a cloud of real-world controversy. Johnny Depp’s exit, Mads Mikkelsen’s sudden casting, and a franchise that suddenly hit the brakes on sequels left fans with plenty of questions the film itself never answered. Here’s everything we know about The Secrets of Dumbledore, what’s settled, and what remains unsolved.

4 related posts

Director: David Yates · Writers: J.K. Rowling and Steve Kloves · Release Year: 2022 · Lead Actor: Eddie Redmayne as Newt Scamander · Key Villain Actor: Mads Mikkelsen as Gellert Grindelwald

Quick snapshot

1Confirmed facts
2What’s unclear
3Timeline signal
4What’s next
  • No fourth film is currently planned; the franchise ends as a trilogy (SYFY franchise tracking)
  • The original plan was five films, but the series capped at three due to box office performance (SYFY franchise tracking)
Field Value
Director David Yates
Screenplay J.K. Rowling and Steve Kloves
Release Date April 2022
Runtime 142 minutes
Main Protagonist Newt Scamander

Why did Johnny Depp not play Grindelwald in The Secrets of Dumbledore?

Johnny Depp portrayed Gellert Grindelwald in the first two Fantastic Beasts films — Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them (2016) and The Crimes of Grindelwald (2018). In November 2020, Warner Bros. asked Depp to resign from the franchise following his libel case loss against News Group Newspapers over domestic abuse allegations made by Amber Heard (The Independent). Depp announced his departure on Instagram, stating he respected the studio’s request. Warner Bros. had initially supported Depp’s casting despite the allegations, with J.K. Rowling and director David Yates expressing comfort with his involvement (UNILAD).

Johnny Depp’s statement

Depp described the recasting as his career “stopped in a millisecond” during filming. He said he felt “shunned, dumped, booted, deep-sixed, cancelled” (The Independent). The actor had already filmed scenes for the third film before being replaced, forcing filmmakers to recast the role entirely.

Mads Mikkelsen replacement

Mads Mikkelsen ultimately replaced Depp as Grindelwald in The Secrets of Dumbledore. Mikkelsen hoped audiences would accept his portrayal after a single scene without directly addressing the recast in the film (ScreenRant). Notably, the film does not acknowledge the real-world recasting — an intentional choice by filmmakers who assumed audiences were already aware of the change. Fan backlash followed Depp’s exit, with many supporting him amid the disputed allegations.

The paradox

The first Fantastic Beasts film featured Colin Farrell disguised as Grindelwald — meaning the franchise had already established actor changes as a plot tradition before the Depp-to-Mikkelsen switch. The real-world recasting echoed a fictional device, giving filmmakers a convenient narrative excuse to normalize the transition.

The catch

Warner Bros. initially supported Depp’s casting despite allegations, with J.K. Rowling and David Yates expressing comfort — only to reverse course months later, illustrating the studio’s reactive approach to real-world controversies that ultimately reshaped the film’s production.

Why were Fantastic Beasts 4 and 5 canceled?

The Fantastic Beasts franchise was originally planned for five films, but plans were scrapped after the third installment underperformed at the box office. The Secrets of Dumbledore released in 2022 with decreasing returns compared to prior films, making sequels increasingly unlikely (SYFY). Warner Bros. ultimately capped the series at three films due to financial performance and ongoing controversies surrounding the franchise.

Official announcements

No formal fourth film has been confirmed. The studio has not issued a detailed public statement explaining the cancellation beyond the implied financial reasoning. The third film’s credits rolled on a trilogy that was never meant to stop at three.

Impact on franchise

The cancellation left several plot threads unresolved, including Credence Barebone’s full backstory and the 13-year timeline gap between the film ending in 1932 and Grindelwald’s defeat in 1945. Depp’s post-franchise work includes directing Modìgliani: Three Days on the Wing of Madness, releasing July 11, 2025.

The implication is that Warner Bros. miscalculated the franchise’s cultural resilience after the real-world controversies proved more damaging to audience reception than anticipated, leaving the Harry Potter universe without a planned bridge to its own history.

Is Fantastic Beasts 4 coming?

No fourth Fantastic Beasts film is currently planned. The trilogy concluded with The Secrets of Dumbledore, and industry reports indicate Warner Bros. shifted focus away from the franchise due to box office trends and the controversies that shadowed the series (SYFY). Fan speculation continues online, but no official development has been announced.

Current status

The franchise exists in limbo — officially complete as a trilogy, unofficially abandoned without closure for several plot mysteries. Production of Secrets of Dumbledore faced pandemic delays, pushing release to April 2022, which may have contributed to shifted audience expectations.

Studio statements

Warner Bros. has not publicly detailed its reasoning beyond financial underperformance. The studio’s silence on future plans leaves the door technically open but practically closed.

What this means is that the 13-year gap to Grindelwald’s 1945 defeat will likely never receive official on-screen resolution, leaving the franchise’s narrative incompleteness permanent.

Bottom line: Johnny Depp fans: his exit came abruptly in November 2020, he felt “shunned, dumped, booted,” and Mads Mikkelsen stepped in without in-film explanation. Warner Bros. halted plans for films four and five citing financial performance, leaving a 13-year narrative gap before Grindelwald’s 1945 defeat. The Fantastic Beasts trilogy ended without resolving its central mysteries.

Is Credence the baby Leta swapped?

The question of Credence Barebone’s true identity carried through all three films without a fully satisfying resolution. In The Crimes of Grindelwald, Newt Scamander was tasked by Dumbledore to find Credence in Paris, believed to be key to stopping Grindelwald (Harry Potter Wiki). The third film hints at family connections involving Leta Lestrange, though the revelation feels incomplete.

Plot revelation

The Secrets of Dumbledore includes hints that Credence may have a blood relation to the Lestrange family, potentially explaining his role as a target in Grindelwald’s plans. However, the film prioritizes the International Confederation of Wizards election subplot over fully resolving Credence’s backstory.

Fantastic Beasts 3 answers

The film does not definitively answer whether Credence is the baby Leta swapped. The mystery was left open-ended, and with the franchise now canceled, this plot point remains unresolved.

The pattern shows the filmmakers introduced the identity mystery as a franchise engine but never delivered the payoff, suggesting either a discarded subplot or a casualty of the truncated production schedule.

What to watch

Without sequels in development, viewers should treat Credence’s storyline as permanently unfinished — a deliberate or accidental loose thread the studio never tied off. The unresolved mystery functions as an unintentional meta-commentary on the franchise’s own incomplete state.

Who killed Gellert Grindelwald?

In the original Harry Potter books, Voldemort kills Grindelwald in 1945, the same year as the Battle of Hogwarts in the novels’ framing. However, the Fantastic Beasts film timeline ends in 1932, leaving 13 years unaccounted for before Grindelwald’s canonical defeat (Harry Potter Theory).

Harry Potter book vs movie

The books establish that Dumbledore defeated Grindelwald in 1945 using the Elder Wand. Voldemort later kills the already-imprisoned Grindelwald in Deathly Hallows to gain control of the wand. The Fantastic Beasts films do not yet cover these events.

Secrets of Dumbledore context

In the third film, Dumbledore and Grindelwald’s clashing spells break their blood pact — made in 1927 to prevent direct confrontation — but Grindelwald escapes after declaring he was never their enemy (Wikipedia). The blood pact had constrained their conflict for decades, and its breaking set up a confrontation that the films never depicted on screen.

Grindelwald uses necromancy to reanimate a dead qilin to influence the ICW election, while Dumbledore’s surviving qilin bows first to him and then to Vicência Santos, leading to her election as ICW head. Grindelwald denounces opposition as madness in his supremacist vision throughout. The implication is that the 13-year gap represents Dumbledore’s continued reluctance to personally confront his former friend, leaving the final reckoning to the future that the films never reached.

Timeline

The Fantastic Beasts saga spans two decades of in-universe history, with the films covering 1927 to 1932 before jumping to Grindelwald’s defeat in 1945 — a gap the movies never explained.

Date/Period Event
2016 Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them release
2018 The Crimes of Grindelwald release
November 2020 Johnny Depp resigns from franchise
April 2022 The Secrets of Dumbledore theatrical release
1932 (in-universe) Film storyline end setting
1927 (in-universe) Blood pact creation between Dumbledore and Grindelwald
1945 (in-universe) Grindelwald’s historical defeat

The timeline reveals how the franchise’s real-world production troubles (Depp’s November 2020 exit) closely mirrored its in-universe blood pact breaking, creating an unsettling parallel between narrative and reality.

Confirmed vs. Unclear

Here’s what we know definitively versus what remains unresolved in the Fantastic Beasts saga:

Confirmed

  • Johnny Depp played Grindelwald in films one and two (2016, 2018)
  • Depp was asked to resign in November 2020
  • Mads Mikkelsen replaced Depp in the third film
  • The Secrets of Dumbledore released April 2022
  • Five films were originally planned; only three released
  • No fourth film is currently planned

Unclear

  • Full details of Credence’s complete arc
  • Whether Warner Bros. issued formal sequel cancellation statement
  • J.K. Rowling’s current stance on franchise future
  • Precise pandemic delay timeline for production
  • Regional release date variations
  • What fills the 13-year gap to 1945

What people are saying

“It literally stopped in a millisecond. Like, while I was doing the movie.”

— Johnny Depp, actor (former Grindelwald) (The Independent)

Depp felt “shunned, dumped, booted, deep-sixed, cancelled.”

— Johnny Depp, actor (former Grindelwald) (UNILAD)

Mikkelsen hoped “all it takes for viewers to adjust to the change is a single scene.”

— Mads Mikkelsen, actor (Grindelwald in third film) (ScreenRant)

Grindelwald defiantly declares that he was never their enemy, and disapparates.

— Gellert Grindelwald (character) (Wikipedia)

Summary

Fantastic Beasts: The Secrets of Dumbledore represents both the high point and the endpoint of a franchise that never found its footing. For Warner Bros., the lesson is clear: real-world controversies can derail even the most carefully planned cinematic universes, and the studio’s reactive handling of Depp’s exit created narrative chaos that no amount of magical world-building could fix. Whether audiences ever see a proper resolution to the Grindelwald saga depends entirely on whether the studio decides the 13-year gap is worth revisiting — or whether the door closes permanently on Newt Scamander’s story.

Johnny Depp’s exit from the franchise proved abrupt and permanent, leaving him to describe his career as “stopped in a millisecond” while Mads Mikkelsen stepped into a role the third film never acknowledged had changed hands.

Related reading: HBO Harry Potter Cast · Percy Jackson Cabin Quiz

Additional sources

youtube.com

The film’s cast recasts and changes brought fresh faces like Mads Mikkelsen as Grindelwald after Johnny Depp’s exit, amid whispers of canceled sequels and Credence plot twists.

Don't miss these

Frequently asked questions

What is Fantastic Beasts: The Secrets of Dumbledore about?

The film is set five years after The Crimes of Grindelwald, with Albus Dumbledore tasking Newt Scamander and allies on a mission to stop Grindelwald’s plans to control the International Confederation of Wizards. Grindelwald is acquitted by ICW head Anton Vogel and runs in elections, using necromancy to reanimate a dead qilin to influence the vote.

Who stars in Fantastic Beasts: The Secrets of Dumbledore?

Eddie Redmayne stars as Newt Scamander, Jude Law as Albus Dumbledore, and Mads Mikkelsen as Gellert Grindelwald (replacing Johnny Depp). Other cast members include Ezra Miller as Credence Barebone and Dan Fogler as Jacob Kowalski.

Where can I watch Fantastic Beasts: The Secrets of Dumbledore?

The film is available on HBO Max (now Max) for streaming subscribers and has been released on home video formats including Blu-ray and DVD. Digital rental and purchase options are available through major platforms.

Is there a book for Fantastic Beasts: The Secrets of Dumbledore?

The film does not have a separate novelization as a standalone release. However, J.K. Rowling’s original Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them screenplay book provides context for the first film in the series.

What is the Rotten Tomatoes score for Fantastic Beasts: The Secrets of Dumbledore?

The film received mixed reviews from critics. For current scores and audience reception data, check Rotten Tomatoes directly as ratings fluctuate with updated reviews and user votes.

How does Fantastic Beasts: The Secrets of Dumbledore connect to Harry Potter?

The film serves as a prequel to the Harry Potter series, depicting events in the 1920s-1930s wizarding world. Albus Dumbledore is the central connecting figure, and the blood pact storyline establishes the foundation for his eventual confrontation with Grindelwald.

Is Albus Dumbledore portrayed as LGBTQ in the films?

J.K. Rowling confirmed Dumbledore’s sexuality as gay, relating to his romantic history with Grindelwald. Jude Law’s portrayal in The Secrets of Dumbledore references this history, though the films do not explicitly state Dumbledore’s orientation on screen.